news: Formula 1
26th June 2002:  Ferrari fined at FIA hearing

 
Michael Schumacher was a controversial winner of the Austrian Grand PrixFerrari have been fined US$1 million for their actions at the recent Austrian Grand Prix when team order's were imposed at the final corner. 

While the FIA stated that they were "with some reluctance" unable to punish the team for manipulating the result, the breach of podium proceedure saw the large fine imposed, half payable immediately and the other half payable should similar incident occur within a year.

At the end of the Austrian Grand Prix, Rubens Barrichello, who had dominated the race from the lights, was ordered to move aside at the final corner to allow through World Championship leader Michael Schumacher, in order for him to earn maximum championship points. With the championship regarded as a foregone conclusion, the teams action's earned them worldwide condemnation from both the media and fans alike.

On the podium, Michael Schumacher, visible shaken by the hostile reaction of the crowd to the result, pushed Rubens Barrichello up onto the top step as the German national anthem was played for the wiinner and then joined him as the Italian anthem was played for the winning constructor.


The full FIA Statement:

FIA Statement 
Having studied the observer's report and heard the three parties concerned, Rubens Barrichello, Michael Schumacher and Scuderia Ferrari Marlboro, the World Motor Sport Council resolved as follows. 

The race 
The WMSC deplored the manner in which team orders were given and executed at the Austrian Grand Prix. Nevertheless the Council finds it impossible to sanction the two drivers, because they were both contractually bound to execute orders given by the team. The Council also recognised the long-standing and traditional right of a team to decree the finishing order of its drivers in what it believes to be the best interest of its attempt to win both World Championships. 

In the circumstances, the Council decided; with some reluctance; that it could take no action over the team orders given by Scuderia Ferrari Marlboro at the Austrian Grand Prix. 

The podium 
The podium procedure was not followed. Having finished second, Rubens Barrichello, who is a Brazilian national, stood on the top step while the German national anthem was played for Michael Schumacher. Michael Schumacher then ascended the top step and both drivers, rather than just the winner, stood there while the Italian national anthem was played. 

Michael Schumacher took the trophy for first place from the Austrian Chancellor, did not acknowledge him, handed the trophy to Rubens Barrichello and then took the second place trophy from the Austrian Deputy Chancellor. It is the duty of each team to ensure that its contracted drivers observe the podium procedures and do not in any way embarrass the national authorities of the country where a grand prix takes place. 

The World Motor Sport Council held that Rubens Barrichello, Michael Schumacher and Scuderia Ferrari Marlboro were each guilty of failure to observe Article 170 of the Formula One Sporting Regulations. The World Motor Sport Council imposed a fine of $1 million on Scuderia Ferrari Marlboro, Michael Schumacher and Rubens Barrichello jointly, half to be paid immediately and half to be suspended for one year. The fine will become payable immediately should a similar offence occur within the next twelve months. 


related articles:

12.05.2002: AUSTRIAN GRAND PRIX REPORT


return to F1 news index